🦷 The Whitening Mistake I Made on My Own Daughter

Whitening your teeth seems simple, right? You buy the strips, apply the gel, or use some trendy LED kit, and boom—brighter teeth.

But what if I told you that most people go about whitening all wrong?

And worse, they end up damaging their enamel in ways they don’t realize until it’s too late.

I know because I made a big mistake with whitening years ago.

Not on myself—on my eldest daughter.

The Whitening Mistake I’ll Never Forget
When my eldest daughter was in sixth grade (about 11 years old), her adult teeth had just come in. Like most kids, they looked darker than her baby teeth.

This is totally normal—baby teeth are naturally whiter because they have less dentin underneath the enamel. But I didn’t realize something critical at the time…

That the pulp inside a child’s tooth is much larger and more vulnerable, and the oxidizing agents in whitening gel can reach it—fast.

So, I used whitening trays with peroxide gel on her teeth for two hours at a time, thinking it was harmless.

But months later, she started noticing sharp sensitivity to cold drinks and foods.

Here’s what was happening:

Whitening gel penetrates the enamel and reaches the dentin layer underneath. Dentin is porous and connected to the pulp—where all the nerves and blood vessels live inside your tooth.

Overuse of whitening products can cause pulp inflammation, which leads to that deep, sharp, shoot-you-out-of-your-chair kind of sensitivity.

Strengthen First—Then Whiten
Here’s what most people (and most dentists) get wrong:

Would you dye or bleach your hair if it was thinning and breaking? Of course not. You’d strengthen it first. The same goes for your teeth.

Whitening is controlled damage. And just like with hair, if your enamel is already weak, you’re going to end up with damage, not just brightness.

That’s why I never recommend whitening unless you’re also rebuilding and strengthening your enamel at the same time.

Here’s how I do that—and what I recommend to every patient before we even talk about whitening:

✅ I make sure I’m getting the right minerals.
Strong enamel doesn’t come from toothpaste alone. Your body needs magnesium, vitamin K2, calcium, phosphorus, and vitamin D to rebuild enamel from the inside out. And most people are deficient—especially in magnesium. Without it, your body can’t properly use calcium and phosphate—the two main minerals in your teeth.

CLICK HERE if you aren’t already taking a magnesium supplement that you love. I’ve been using this one for many years now and I don’t like to ever miss a day of magnesium.

✅ I use hydroxyapatite toothpaste.
Fluoride hardens enamel—but it also leaves a rough, uneven surface that picks up stains. Nano-hydroxyapatite rebuilds enamel in a smooth, light-reflecting way, which helps your teeth appear naturally whiter—while actually getting stronger.

CLICK HERE for the nano-hydroxyapatite toothpaste I created.

✅ I avoid coffee, wine, and acidic foods for at least 24 hours after whitening.
If I do have them, I use a straw and rinse right after. That window right after whitening is when your enamel is most porous—and most vulnerable.

My Must-Haves for Whitening the Right Way
I still whiten my teeth—but I do it in a way that protects them at the same time.
Because if you go too hard, too fast, or skip the steps that fortify your enamel, you’ll end up with sensitivity, soft enamel, and teeth that stain faster.

1. First, Ask Yourself: Do You Even Need Whitening?
Most people think they need whitening, when what they really need is stain removal.
Here’s how to tell:

• When was your last professional cleaning? Plaque and tartar buildup can make teeth look yellow even when they’re not.
• Do you drink coffee, tea, or red wine? These cause external stains that may not need whitening—just polishing.
• Is your enamel naturally more yellow? Some people have thicker dentin or more translucent enamel. Whitening can only do so much.

If you’ve checked these boxes and still want to whiten, move on to Step 2 below…

2. My Must-Haves for Safe, Effective Whitening
Custom Whitening Trays + 10% Carbamide Peroxide Gel
This is the gold standard. Custom trays ensure even application, prevent gum irritation, and let you whiten gradually—without extreme sensitivity.

I like the Opalescence brand which can be found on Amazon.

🚫 What to Avoid:

• Crest Whitestrips – Even the “Professional Effects” version contains adhesives and other chemicals that help the strips stick to your enamel—but they can also disrupt the oral microbiome. Not to mention, the results can’t compare to what you get with custom trays because whitestrips aren’t 3D, but teeth are!
• LED Whitening Kits – These look high-tech, but there’s zero peer-reviewed evidence that blue light improves whitening results. The science just isn’t there.
• Lumineux & “natural” whitening products – If it doesn’t contain peroxide, it’s not actually whitening. These mostly remove surface stains.
• Whitening toothpastes – Abrasive, strip enamel, and ironically, lead to more yellowing over time.
• Too much peroxide – More isn’t better. It weakens enamel and can cause long-term pulp damage.

• Anything with lemons or strawberries – these methods make the rounds on Instagram and Pinterest and the acids are just terrible for teeth!

Whitening Is Fine—If You Do It Right
I’m not here to tell you whitening is bad. I do it myself.

But I’m also not going to be the dentist who just hands you a whitening kit without asking questions.

Whitening without strengthening is asking for trouble. But do it the right way—support your enamel, go slow, and protect your pulp—and you’ll get long-lasting results without the regrets.

Next week, we’re talking stain removal—because a lot of people don’t actually need whitening. Hit reply with your questions on this topic!

Until then, be good to your teeth and have a great weekend!

– Mark

Know someone who would appreciate this?
Forward it to them & tell them to sign up for future emails here.

P.S. What whitening method have you tried in the past—and how did it go? Hit reply and let me know. I read every message.